Applying the acquisition method: Key areas of judgment
Once a transaction is determined to be a business combination, the acquisition method applies. At a high level, this involves identifying the acquirer, measuring consideration transferred, and recording the assets and liabilities at fair value—with limited exceptions. Each of these steps can introduce complexity.
Identifying the acquirer
The accounting acquirer is the entity that obtains control, which may differ from the legal acquirer. Identifying the acquirer isn’t always straightforward, particularly in transactions involving multiple entities or exchanges of equity consideration.
Additionally, new legal entities may be established to facilitate the transaction, and such entities may not be substantive for ASC 805-purposes to qualify as the accounting acquirer.
When evaluating the acquirer, companies often consider:
- The relative size of the combining entities
- The composition of the governing body and senior management of the combined entity
- Which party initiated the transaction
- Whether any party holds a large minority voting interest in the absence of a controlling shareholder or group
- The relative voting rights in the combined entity after the business combination
- The terms of the exchange of equity interests
This conclusion matters because the identified acquirer is responsible for recording the purchase accounting entries, which generally reflect the fair value of the assets acquired and liabilities assumed of the acquiree.
Determining consideration transferred
Determining what constitutes the fair value of consideration transferred is another area that requires careful analysis. In addition to cash payments to sellers on close, consideration may commonly include:
- Equity of the acquirer issued to the seller
- Contingent payments, such as earnouts
- Settling liabilities of the seller at or near the transaction close date
- Payments of seller transaction expenses on behalf of the seller
US GAAP often considers cash payments to settle seller liabilities, such as debt, as cash consideration transferred if such settlement occurs at or near the transaction close date and the liability isn’t legally assumed by the acquirer. If a liability is legally assumed by the acquirer, it generally wouldn’t be included as part of consideration transferred.
The acquirer is required to assess whether the amounts transferred include transactions separate from the business combination. Common transactions that are to be accounted for separate from the acquisition accounting include transactions that:
- Settle a preexisting relationship between the entities
- Compensate employees or former owners for future services
- Reimburse the acquiree for payment of acquirer transaction costs
Contingent payments often require judgment to determine whether they should be included in consideration transferred.
If the payment is contingent upon future services, including employee-related services to be provided by existing employees after the seller closes the transaction, it’s considered a compensation arrangement outside the scope of acquisition accounting.
Additionally, if contingent consideration is included as part of consideration transferred, management must assess whether the contingent consideration is equity or liability classified, (or in rare cases an asset), with liability classification requiring subsequent mark-to-market remeasurement through the income statement after the transaction closes. Note that cash-settled contingent consideration is generally liability-classified.
It’s also important to consider whether any portion of the transaction relates to the settlement of preexisting relationships between the buyer and seller. Arrangements such as supply agreements, lending relationships, or disputes may effectively be settled as part of the deal. In those cases, a portion of the payment would need to be accounted for separately from the business combination.
Measuring assets acquired and liabilities assumed
After determining consideration transferred, the next step is measuring the assets acquired and liabilities assumed, generally at fair value.
This includes a range of assets and obligations, such as:
- Working capital, such as accounts receivable, inventory, and accounts payable
- Tangible assets, such as equipment and real estate
- Identifiable intangible assets, such as customer relationships, trade names, and technology
- Assumed debt and other liabilities, including acquired lease liabilities and contingent or less visible obligations
While the general principle is to measure assets acquired and liabilities assumed at fair value, there are certain exceptions. For example, contract assets and deferred revenue that are acquired in a business combination are to be recorded at their historical basis in accordance with the acquiree’s application of revenue guidance.
In addition, as a practical matter, an acquirer may conclude that some recorded book balances approximate fair value and wouldn’t require significant adjustment. This assessment requires judgment and should be supported based on the underlying facts and circumstances, with an appropriate level of evidence.
Goodwill is then calculated as the excess of total consideration over the acquisition date value of identifiable net assets. Importantly, this calculation reflects the value of the entire business. It includes:
- The fair value of consideration transferred
- The fair value of any noncontrolling interest
- In a business combination achieved in stages, the acquisition date fair value of previously held equity interests in the acquiree
As a result, goodwill represents a full entity valuation, capturing expected synergies and other future economic benefits.
Because goodwill is a residual amount, it’s highly sensitive to the judgments made in valuing both consideration and the underlying assets and liabilities. Changes in those assumptions can significantly affect the amount recorded and, in turn, future earnings through impairment or amortization. As a result, careful evaluation of underlying value drivers and clear documentation are critical to supporting the overall accounting outcome.