3. Can they get the care they need when they need it?
A well-designed care model that patients can’t reach is theoretical. And the honest version of the access question isn’t "is the schedule full." It’s: are our patients getting the care they need in a timely manner? Are the maintenance, follow-up, and preventive visits based on their clinical health requirements?
That is why this question loops back to the first. Without a clear picture of what the population requires, access to care can’t be honestly evaluated. A packed schedule or full hospital unit can coexist with a population whose chronic conditions are deteriorating between visits.
The system-wide picture is challenging—and even the published benchmarks fall well short of what a high health-burden population needs. IHS established a standard of 28 days for primary care and 48 hours for urgent care in 2017. For a clinic population carrying diabetes prevalence in the double digits and cardiovascular mortality decades ahead of the general population, a 28-day wait for primary care isn’t a sufficient target—it’s a description of a system operating well below what its patients require. And the Government Accountability Office has flagged that many facilities can’t reliably measure whether they meet even that modest standard, because the underlying data infrastructure doesn’t produce the metrics cleanly.
A path forward
The work has three parts. First, measure access honestly: in the ambulatory setting, assess how long it takes to get an appointment by visit type and clinical urgency, no-show and cancellation rates by provider or care team, and how well care gaps are being closed for patients with chronic conditions.
Second, define a target condition that reflects what the population requires—not what the standards permit. For a patient population with this health impact, target waits are measured in days for routine care and hours for urgent care, not weeks and days.
Third, pursue the clinical throughput work required to achieve your target: right-size the number of patients assigned to meet the acuity of your patients, design patient-centered care through workflow optimization, scheduling redesign, standing protocols that let non-provider team members work at the top of license, and disciplined management of referral and follow-up loops.
This is operational transformation work, and it ensures that community members get the care they need, when they need it, for both curative and preventive care.
What a clear answer makes possible
The organization can distinguish between a schedule that is full and a population that is being cared for. Investments in scheduling, staffing, and workflow can be targeted at the specific access failures affecting outcomes, rather than spread across generic capacity expansion. Chronic disease outcomes begin to improve because patients are getting the visits their conditions demand.
Overall capacity, staffing, and workflows are designed to support the patients you serve—improving continuity of care, access, patient outcomes, and clinician wellbeing. And leadership can respond to patient and community feedback with confidence—a much stronger footing for the difficult conversations access issues often surface.
4. How do we ensure we can retain a team to care for our patients?
Everything the first three questions describe depends on continuity. Culture, mission focus, clinical quality, patient trust—none of these survive constant turnover. The care model surfaced by the first two questions is only as consistent as the team delivering it.
Workforce stability is a precondition for effective care. Turnover in clinical roles doesn’t just create scheduling problems. It breaks the continuity that makes team-based care possible, resets patient relationships every eighteen months, and absorbs the leadership energy that should be going into strategic work.
And it’s worth being honest about what drives that turnover. Compensation is a real challenge—IHS and Tribal health facilities have long struggled to match private-sector market salaries and benefits. But the research on clinician retention points consistently to a second set of drivers that matter as much or more. A study of physicians and midlevel providers in the Navajo Area IHS found that the most cited reason for planning to leave was lack of administrative support and quality—not pay—with excessive working hours ranking among the top drivers. The American Medical Association's Organizational Biopsy has documented the same pattern nationally, identifying administrative burden, workflow inefficiency, and staffing shortages as dominant contributors to burnout and intent to leave. Retention, examined closely, is largely a function of the operational conditions the first three questions in this framework are designed to improve.
The environment is difficult. IHS-system provider vacancy rates average approximately 25% nationally, with some regions running 40–50% and some rural facilities reporting higher still. Those are the ambient conditions the sector is operating in—but they’re not any single organization's own numbers. What matters is whether leadership can answer the forward-looking version of the question: not "what is our vacancy rate today," but "what do we know about who is staying, and why."