One federal framework, different state environments
Federal regulations establish important consistency for federally funded engineering and design-related contracts.
Under 23 CFR Part 172, indirect cost rates generally must be updated annually in accordance with the consultant's accounting period and applicable federal cost principles. The regulation also establishes the framework for cognizant indirect cost rates. When a cognizant rate has been established in accordance with the federal requirements, contracting agencies generally must accept that rate. Accepted rates are used for purposes including contract estimation, negotiation, administration, reporting, and payment. But a common federal foundation doesn’t mean every state process looks the same.
The 2024 AASHTO Audit and Accounting Guide, issued by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials, provides another common reference point for A&E firms, state DOT auditors, and CPAs. The updated guide places additional emphasis on areas such as risk assessment, linking identified risks to audit procedures, audit sampling, and evaluating audit results.
Consider the documentation required by several State DOTs
Oregon DOT's (ODOT) current indirect cost-rate submission checklist calls for items including an indirect cost-rate schedule, Cost Disclosure Questionnaire, financial statements, an independent audit when applicable, cognizant audit information when available, executive compensation analysis, an internal bonus policy, certification of final indirect costs, and other supporting information. ODOT also requests indirect cost-rate acceptance letters from other state transportation agencies when available.
Washington State DOT (WSDOT) has its own indirect cost-rate review process and supporting forms. The documentation and review path can vary depending on whether the firm submits a cognizant rate, CPA-audited rate, or consultant-prepared rate. WSDOT also publishes specific interpretive guidance addressing matters such as labor, bonuses, airfare, meals, vehicles, and uncompensated overtime.
California adds another dimension. Caltrans’s financial-document requirements address the age of the rate used for a procurement and, in specified circumstances, require separate home-office and field-office rates. Caltrans also requires supporting financial documentation and addresses matters such as uncompensated overtime and facilities capital cost of money.
Texas uses an administrative qualification process to verify indirect cost rates. TxDOT distinguishes between federal and nonfederal processes and has specific policies governing combined, home-office and field-office rates. Firms maintaining an administrative qualification generally must submit updated qualification documentation annually.
These differences aren’t simply paperwork. They illustrate why a firm that’s comfortable with the federal cost principles may still encounter challenges as it expands into additional state markets.
A portable rate starts with the accounting system
In practice, many indirect cost rate issues originate long before anyone prepares the annual schedule.
By year-end, employees have already charged thousands of hours, expenses have been classified, bonuses have been awarded, and business development and travel costs have been incurred. Acquisitions, reorganization, or new offices may have changed the business.
The rate reflects those decisions. It can’t retroactively create the accounting discipline that should have existed throughout the year.
Labor charging is a good example. Because direct labor commonly serves as the allocation base for A&E indirect cost rates, inconsistent timekeeping or labor classification can affect more than individual projects. Firms should have policies governing direct and indirect labor, corrections to timesheets, and supervisory review, and those policies should align with actual practice.
Cost allowability requires the same discipline. A strong system identifies and segregates applicable unallowable costs when they’re incurred rather than depending entirely on a year-end exercise to find them.
This becomes particularly important because 23 CFR Part 172 requires an executive or financial officer to certify that the costs included in the final indirect cost-rate proposal are allowable under the applicable federal cost principles and don’t include expressly unallowable costs.
The strongest indirect cost-rate process therefore begins with the general ledger, timekeeping system, and internal controls, not with the spreadsheet used to calculate the final percentage.