Key takeaways
- The New Jersey Tax Court upheld the Division of Taxation’s regulation treating synchronous technical support, such as electronic chat and internet help desks, as in-state business activity under P.L. 86-272, even without physical presence in New Jersey.
- The court agreed that asynchronous communications, such as website FAQs, do not constitute in-state business activity but declined to determine the treatment of email support or machine-generated responses due to an insufficient factual record.
- The court declined to rule on the validity of the regulation’s treatment of cookies used to gather and assemble customer or market data for sale to third parties because neither party presented evidence of sellers assembling data for sale.
A New Jersey Tax Court decision raises important questions for out-of-state sellers about when online customer support and other internet activities may jeopardize their P.L. 86-272 state income tax protection.
What does P.L. 86-272 protect, and how does New Jersey regulate internet activities?
P.L. 86-272 generally prohibits a state from imposing a net income tax on income derived from interstate commerce when an out-of-state seller's only business activities in the state are the solicitation of orders for tangible personal property (TPP), the orders are approved or rejected outside the state, and approved orders are filled by shipment or delivery from outside the state.
On June 16, 2025, the Division of Taxation adopted N.J.A.C. 18:7-1.9A, addressing internet activities that may exceed P.L. 86-272 protection. The regulation applies to foreign corporations that otherwise have nexus with New Jersey and identifies internet activities that the division considers sufficient to exceed P.L. 86-272 protection and subject a corporation to New Jersey’s Corporation Business Tax.
Among those activities, the regulation identifies post-sale assistance provided through electronic chat, email or an application, including troubleshooting, complaint resolution and an internet help desk through which a customer can communicate with a service representative. The regulation separately provides that posting an FAQ on a webpage does not, by itself, exceed P.L. 86-272 protection.
The regulation also addresses internet cookies. Cookies used ancillary to the solicitation of orders do not, by themselves, exceed P.L. 86-272 protection. By contrast, the regulation identifies as unprotected the placement of cookies on New Jersey customers' computers that gather market or product research when the taxpayer gathers and assembles that data for sale as customer or marketing information to data brokers or other third parties.
The American Catalog Mailers Association (ACMA), a trade association whose members include out-of-state internet sellers of TPP, filed a declaratory judgment action challenging the regulation. ACMA's members provide interactive technical support to New Jersey customers and place tracking cookies on the computers of prospective and actual customers. ACMA argued that P.L. 86-272 preempted the challenged provisions of the regulation. The parties filed cross-motions for summary judgment, and on Oct. 1, 2026, the New Jersey Tax Court issued its opinion.
Businesses relying on P.L. 86-272 in New Jersey should consider reviewing their online customer-support functions in light of the court's distinction between synchronous and asynchronous communications.
Does P.L. 86-272 require physical presence in New Jersey?
The court considered whether P.L. 86-272 preempted the challenged provisions of the division's regulation. In doing so, the court first addressed whether P.L. 86-272 requires physical presence in New Jersey to establish a business activity within the state.
The court reviewed the historical development of state taxation of interstate commerce and P.L. 86-272. It concluded that Congress did not displace the economic-activity standard for state income taxation or impose a physical-presence requirement when it enacted P.L. 86-272. Instead, the court concluded that Congress retained the economic-activity standard while creating an exception for sellers of TPP whose in-state business activities are limited to solicitation and whose orders are approved and fulfilled outside the state.
The court also relied on South Dakota v. Wayfair, Inc., in which the U.S. Supreme Court held that physical presence is not required to establish substantial nexus for sales tax purposes. According to the Tax Court, Wayfair supported the conclusion that a seller may conduct business activity within a state through modern technology without being physically present there. The court emphasized, however, that P.L. 86-272 continues to protect sellers of TPP whose in-state business activities remain limited to solicitation. Accordingly, the relevant inquiry under P.L. 86-272 is whether a seller conducts business activities within New Jersey beyond solicitation, rather than whether the seller is physically present in the state.
When does online technical support exceed P.L. 86-272 protection?
Applying that framework, the court considered the regulation's treatment of interactive technical support. The parties did not dispute that technical support is a business activity or contend that it constitutes solicitation. Instead, the issue was whether the technical-support communications were attributable to the seller's out-of-state location or the customer's location in New Jersey.
The court distinguished synchronous from asynchronous communications. It agreed that FAQs posted on websites aren’t business activities conducted within New Jersey because the information is assembled outside the state and later accessed by the customer. For synchronous communications, such as electronic chat and an internet help desk for technical support, however, the court concluded that the seller is reaching into New Jersey and interacting with the customer.
The court determined that such support occurs both outside New Jersey where the seller provides it and within New Jersey where the customer receives it. Because the technical support has an in-state component and does not constitute solicitation, the court upheld the regulation's treatment of synchronous technical support as a business activity occurring within New Jersey that exceeds P.L. 86-272 protection.
The court declined to establish a categorical rule for email. It observed that email may have an interactive quality similar to synchronous communications when responses occur in near real time, while an email answered days later may be more analogous to regular mail or a static FAQ.
Because the regulation doesn’t establish a response-time standard and the record did not address ACMA members' email practices, the court declined to determine when email technical support constitutes an in-state business activity.
The court similarly declined to determine whether machine-generated responses or chatbots constitute synchronous communications, concluding that the answer may depend on how the technology operates. The court also recognized that de minimis in-state business activities don’t defeat P.L. 86-272 protection, citing as an example a seller of household chemicals providing an emergency telephone number for customers to call in the event of ingestion or poisoning.
Do internet cookies and third-party analytics affect P.L. 86-272 protection?
The court separately considered the regulation's treatment of internet cookies but declined to rule on the validity of the challenged cookie provision.
The regulation provides that cookies used ancillary to solicitation do not, by themselves, exceed P.L. 86-272 protection. Conversely, the regulation provides that cookies exceed P.L. 86-272 protection when they gather market or product research and the taxpayer gathers and assembles the resulting data for sale to data brokers or other third parties.
The court observed that the factual arrangement described in the regulation did not appear to correspond to the prevailing understanding of how cookies and third-party analytics tools operate, as reflected in the authorities it reviewed. Under those arrangements, third-party analytics companies generally deploy or read cookies and collect customer data, while providing analytics to sellers. Neither party presented evidence that sellers themselves were assembling customer data for sale.
The court therefore declined to pass on the validity of the cookie provision without evidence of sellers engaging in the activity described in the regulation. The court observed that, under the prevailing arrangement, sellers allow third-party analytics companies to deploy cookies and gather customer data, while the third parties provide analytics to the sellers. The court stated that, if the division views that arrangement as a quid pro quo that rises to the level of a New Jersey business activity, the regulation would need to expressly address it rather than have the court rewrite the existing provision.
The court ultimately denied ACMA's motion for summary judgment, granted the division's motion, and dismissed the complaint.
What does the New Jersey P.L. 86-272 decision mean for out-of-state businesses?
Businesses relying on P.L. 86-272 in New Jersey should consider reviewing their online customer-support functions in light of the court's distinction between synchronous and asynchronous communications. In particular, businesses with live chat, help desks, email or automated support functions should consider whether the decision may affect their P.L. 86-272 position based on their particular facts.
Businesses should also consider reviewing their cookie and third-party analytics arrangements. The court did not decide whether the prevailing third-party analytics model constitutes a New Jersey business activity and indicated that the regulation would need to expressly address that arrangement if the division intends to treat it as such.
Our State and Local Tax professionals will continue to monitor developments related to the decision and New Jersey's application of P.L. 86-272 to internet activities. Our team is available to assist businesses with evaluating their P.L. 86-272 positions, including the potential impact of their online activities on their New Jersey Corporation Business Tax filing positions.

