Why it matters
The evidence for team-based performance isn’t new, and it isn’t thin.
Healthcare’s dependence on teams extends from the bedside to the executive suite. Patient care depends on coordination across disciplines; organizational performance depends on coordination across functions.
The implications are clearest at the leadership level. Executive teams determine which priorities receive attention, where resources go, which risks are elevated and how competing demands are resolved. They connect strategy to operations. When the executive team works well, the organization can adjust without losing direction. When it does not, even a sound strategy can stall.
The challenge is integration. No individual leader sees the whole picture, and decisions involving staffing, access, quality, finance, technology and growth rarely remain within one function. Even a strong plan changes once it meets operational reality.
McKinsey’s research on high-performing teams reinforces a consistent point: strong leadership teams do more than assemble talented executives. They create a shared direction, make decisions effectively, draw out different perspectives, and build enough trust for candid debate.
Team size can make that harder. McKinsey’s research suggests that effectiveness may begin to decline as teams grow beyond roughly 10 members—a relevant consideration for healthcare executive teams, which often expand as more functions and constituencies seek representation.
The issue isn’t simply the number of people around the table—it’s whether the team is still able to operate as a team. As executive teams grow, they need greater discipline about who participates in which decisions, how competing perspectives are surfaced and integrated, and where accountability ultimately rests.
Without that clarity, the executive team can gradually become a collection of functional representatives sharing updates rather than a leadership team making enterprise decisions together.
Healthcare research follows the same pattern. Studies have linked top management team leadership and executive dynamics with clinical governance, patient complaints, quality, and financial outcomes. Research across sectors also finds that shared leadership predicts team effectiveness better than any single leader’s traits, while healthcare studies connect strong leadership with lower burnout, better safety compliance, and lower readmission rates.
Put simply: the executive team, not the individual, is where a growing share of organizational performance is decided.
We’ve seen this work in healthcare
The best-known example of structured team development in healthcare is TeamSTEPPS—Team Strategies and Tools to Enhance Performance and Patient Safety—developed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality and the Department of Defense. It’s built on four teachable competencies: communication, team leadership, situation monitoring, and mutual support.
The evidence is substantial. Studies of TeamSTEPPS have found improvements in communication, patient safety, clinical error rates, patient satisfaction, and safety culture. North Shore-LIJ, now Northwell, trained more than 40,000 staff across its network and reported improvements in care, mortality, patient harm, infection rates, and malpractice expenses.
Where TeamSTEPPS has failed to produce results, the reason has been consistent: training without effective implementation and sustained institutional commitment may produce little change. The framework works. The commitment has to match.
TeamSTEPPS is a clinical intervention, but the principle travels: teamwork can be taught, practiced, and reinforced. Leadership teams need the same level of intention. Patrick Lencioni’s work offers one practical description of the behaviors involved.
The behaviors of high-performing leadership teams
Patrick Lencioni’s framework, popularized in The Five Dysfunctions of a Team and now widely taught in some form by leadership consulting firms, describes five behaviors that build on one another sequentially:
- Trust. Specifically, vulnerability-based trust. Team members are willing to say “I don’t know,” “I was wrong,” or “I need help.”
- Productive conflict. Real debate about ideas. Teams that trust each other argue well, and better decisions result.
- Commitment. Genuine buy-in to decisions once they’re made. This requires that everyone’s voice has been heard.
- Accountability. Peer-to-peer, not just top-down. Teams must hold one another to their commitments instead of waiting for a leader to do it.
- Attention to results. The collective outcome outweighs individual or departmental wins. In healthcare terms: nobody celebrates their unit’s numbers while the patient’s outcome is worse.
Each behavior enables the ones above it, and each addresses a practical performance problem. Trust helps bad news and uncertainty surface. Productive conflict brings competing assumptions into the room. Commitment creates clarity. Peer accountability catches slippage before every issue reaches the leader, and attention to results keeps departmental success from standing in for enterprise progress. When executive teams model these behaviors, they cascade throughout the organization; when they don’t, dysfunction cascades in exactly the same way.
Leaders differ in how they communicate, decide, respond to pressure, and assess risk. Self-awareness helps those differences become useful rather than disruptive. But insight alone does not change performance. The behaviors have to show up in meetings, decisions, problem-solving, coaching, and follow-through.
Focus on real outcomes when building teams
There’s an important distinction for skeptical leaders. Developing team behaviors doesn’t happen during a retreat, personality assessment, rope-swing exercise, or off-site dinner. Those experiences rarely change behavior.
Developing high-performing teams looks more like TeamSTEPPS than a one-time team event. It’s structured, disciplined, and ongoing, with specific behaviors taught and reinforced over time. It has diagnostics, tools, measurable outcomes, and the same institutional commitment expected of clinical training programs.
Knowing the behaviors isn’t the same as using them. The test is whether they show up in regular work—especially when pressure is high, information is incomplete, and functional priorities compete.
The tools exist and the work can be structured. What’s missing in many healthcare organizations isn’t another model. It’s the decision to treat team development as a real investment rather than a nice-to-have.
What you get in return
The benefits compound. Leaders in high-performing teams report higher engagement, lower burnout, and better decisions. Organizationally, the outcomes track what health systems are already trying to improve: safer care, patient experience, financial performance, retention, and strategic execution. When the executive leadership team functions well, strategy gets implemented. When it does not, even strong plans can die in the tension between the people expected to execute them.
There’s a cultural multiplier. When executive teams model trust, productive conflict, and shared accountability, those behaviors cascade downward. A dysfunctional leadership team quietly licenses dysfunction elsewhere; a high-functioning one raises the standard for every team, department, and unit.
How does your team operate under pressure?
Ask yourself the following questions aimed at teams that work reasonably well on the surface—meetings are orderly, relationships are professional, and no obvious dysfunction demands attention. But a team can be effective enough to get by without operating at a high-performing level. The gap often shows up in patterns like these:
- When someone on your team makes a mistake, do they raise it first, or does someone else surface it?
- In your last three leadership meetings, was there a genuine disagreement voiced in the room—or did the real disagreements happen afterward, in the hallway or on side calls?
- When a decision is made, does the team leave the room aligned, or does implementation get quietly renegotiated over the next two weeks?
- Do your team members hold each other accountable, or does every performance conversation have to go through you?
- When your unit or department has a great quarter but the broader organization misses its goals, does that feel like a win or a loss to your team?
For struggling teams, the answers are sharper: mistakes stay hidden until they become crises, meetings are performative, decisions are revisited, accountability is entirely top-down, and departmental wins are celebrated while enterprise goals go unmet.
The point isn’t the label. It’s recognizing that we get along and the numbers are fine isn’t the same as operating as a high-performing team at its full potential. Most healthcare leadership teams sit somewhere in the middle, and few have been developed with the intent of moving up.
Turn individual excellence into collective performance
Healthcare has spent a generation developing individuals. That work matters and should continue. But the next step—for patient outcomes, financial performance, retention, and execution—is to develop the teams delivering care and running the organization with the same discipline.
The evidence has been available for two decades. The frameworks work.
What’s required now is the leadership decision to treat team development with the same seriousness long given to individual development—beginning with the executive team. When senior leaders model and reinforce the practices of high-performing teams, those behaviors set the standard for each level of leadership below them.
Organizations that start at the top will be better positioned to turn individual excellence into collective performance. The rest will keep wondering why strong leaders and strong plans aren’t producing the results they expected.