1. Cybersecurity exercises continue to expose preparedness gaps
Cybersecurity topped the survey's list of concerns at the beginning of 2026, cited by 92% of respondents. It remains a persistent area of risk as financial institutions contend with sophisticated cybercriminals, third-party dependencies, and an expanding technology environment.
Financial institutions are taking steps to test their preparedness. Among CEOs and senior technology executives surveyed, 89% said their institution had conducted a tabletop exercise of its cybersecurity incident response plan during the prior 12 months.
Those exercises identified important vulnerabilities. 36% identified overreliance on one individual or function, while 35% identified gaps in internal communications. Vendor vulnerabilities were identified by 22%, and 21% cited overreliance on vendors for key functions.
Notably, 26% reported finding no gaps during their most recent exercise.
The evolving cyber environment provides a reason for institutions to continue challenging their assumptions. Tabletop exercises can test not only whether an incident response plan exists, but also how teams communicate, how decisions are escalated, whether roles are understood, and how effectively the institution can operate when normal systems or processes are unavailable.
Key takeaway
A tabletop exercise should help an institution discover where its response capabilities can improve, not simply validate that an existing plan works on paper. Scenarios should evolve along with the threat environment.
Incorporating third-party disruptions, AI-enabled attacks, communication failures, and other realistic complications can help institutions identify weaknesses before an actual incident occurs.
2. Financial institutions are reconsidering their appetite for strategic risk
At the beginning of 2026, 42% of survey respondents identified strategic risk as a top concern, compared with 30% in 2025. At the same time, 53% said their institution could be more aggressive and take greater strategic risk.
More than halfway through 2026, that tension remains relevant, and was one of the most intriguing takeaways from the survey. It’s also a theme we continue to explore with financial institution executives through Baker Tilly’s Bank Leadership Lab: When every risk feels urgent, how do leaders determine where to focus and where taking calculated risk may be necessary to position the institution for what’s next?
As financial institutions navigate AI, digital assets, emerging technologies, and evolving customer expectations, strong capital and liquidity positions present opportunities to pursue growth, acquisitions, and strategic investments.
For boards and management, the focus isn’t only on risks to avoid, but also on whether the institution is positioned to capitalize on opportunities. A well-defined risk appetite helps guide these decisions by aligning risk-taking with strategy, identifying where additional controls are needed, and avoiding excessive caution that could hinder competitiveness.
Key takeaway
Financial institutions should periodically reassess whether their risk appetite remains aligned with their strategy, particularly as technology, competition and customer expectations continue to evolve.
3. AI is intensifying an already challenging fraud environment
Fraud was already a significant concern when the survey was conducted, with 79% of respondents identifying it as a top risk.
Traditional forms of fraud remained widespread. Among CEOs, chief risk officers, and senior technology executives surveyed, 99% said their institution or its customers had been directly impacted by check fraud over the prior 18 months. Financial exploitation of elderly or vulnerable customers was reported by 84%, while 73% reported digital payments fraud.
AI adds another dimension to the challenge. When asked about risks associated with AI, 84% of CEOs, chief risk officers, and senior technology executives identified increasingly sophisticated fraud and scams targeting customers as a concern, and 77% cited scams targeting the institution or its employees.
Those concerns remain highly relevant as AI tools continue to become more capable and accessible.
Generative AI can make social engineering and impersonation attempts more sophisticated and easier to scale. Deepfake technologies can generate increasingly convincing audio, images, and video, challenging controls that historically relied on an individual's ability to recognize a known customer, executive, or colleague.
Key takeaway
Financial institutions should evaluate whether their fraud controls and verification processes are keeping pace with the increasingly sophisticated tools available to bad actors. Institutions should consider whether fraud risk assessments, authentication and verification processes, employee training, and customer education reflect the changing threat environment.
Greater coordination across fraud, cybersecurity, and other financial crime functions may also become increasingly valuable as these risks converge.